Skip to main content

Posts

A Brighter Summer Day (1991)

Precisely two hours into this four-hour historical drama, we see an exchange between two children at school.  One of them is Xiao Si'r, the film’s main character and a member of a gang of delinquent teens.  The other is Ming, a girl who used to be in a relationship with Honey, the leader of Si'r's gang.   Honey is absent for most of the film, having skipped town and gone into hiding after killing a member of a rival gang.  Honey and S'ir's gang is for children of families who immigrated to Taiwan after the Chinese Civil War.  The rival gang is for children of native Taiwanese.    As Si'r and Ming talk, the camera remains at a distance from them, but we can hear their voices as if they were close.  In the background, we can hear the school’s marching band practicing.  It’s loud enough that it would certainly drown out Si'r and Ming’s voices if they weren’t amplified for us.  Ming recounts to Si'r how alone she felt duri...

The Hateful Eight (2015)

The script for  The Hateful Eight  is the first mystery Quentin Tarantino has written, according to him, and the traditional methods of building mystery narratives differ from those he normally employs when writing.  Perhaps this is why  The Hateful Eight 's mystery is, to say the least, idiosyncratic: even as the evidence mounts, the truth only comes out when everything spirals out of the characters' control.  But this is for the best.  The anti-mystery of  The Hateful Eight  throws other elements of the film into perspective. Tarantino said the film would not work as a play, and he's right.  At least, it does things that could not be imitated on stage.  After all the key players have organized in Minnie's Haberdashery, we get a brief moment that singles out small elements of their surroundings, elements we soon realize are meant to be clues.  When the significance of these clues is finally revealed, it's not because any of t...

Anomalisa (2015)

Anomalisa  opens with a shot of an airplane moving through the clouds. We can hear the voices of various people before the camera pulls back and reveals that we were seeing through the window of another airplane, and from the perspective of the main character, Michael Stone.  Michael is a quasi-famous expert on customer service traveling to Cincinnati to give a lecture to some business professionals. Like many, many films, Anomalisa suggests that everything we see is part of a character's unreliable perspective.  This opening scene sets the stage for the symbolic device that dominates the film.  All but two characters in the film, regardless of age or sex, have the same face and Tom Noonan's voice.  Only Michael and the film's title character, Lisa, are unique.  Something is seriously wrong with how Michael receives other people. After landing in Cincinnati, Michael checks in at the Fregoli Hotel, where the rest of the film takes place.  This ...

Black Coal, Thin Ice (2014)

Black Coal, Thin Ice takes place in a world where neon lights cast sickly, artificial colors over everything in a desperate attempt to mask the chaos.  It's a genre movie to its core, the plot composed almost entirely of elements from the films noir of the 1940s, but any lack of narrative originality is more than compensated for by how beautifully unsettling it is as an aesthetic experience. The film begins in 1999, with a police investigation.  Dismembered body parts have been found in coal shipments scattered all over the province.  The film's opening switches between images of a severed arm and a yet-unidentified man.  We wonder if he might be the murderer, or even the victim. We soon realize he's actually Detective Zhang, an cop assigned to the investigation.  Based on clothes found at the scene, the police find that the victim was a man named Liang Zhijun.  Zhang goes to speak with Liang's wife, Wu Zhizhen, who works at a laundromat, but she is ...

Jeanne Dielman, 23 Quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles (1975)

The camera in Jeanne Dielman, 23 Quai du Commerce, 1080 Bruxelles  is low, and the frame often feels a bit narrow.  This is limiting for us viewers, but not for Jeanne Dielman , who is free to walk out of the frame and out of our sight without the camera following her.  The film shows us a character's daily life in rigorous detail, but it doesn't feel voyeuristic.  There is no pleasure derived from the sense that we're seeing something not intended for our eyes.  We have no power, and our attention is directed less toward people than to processes and a particular balance of objects.  This is all more important than the plot, which can be summarized as follows: A woman named Jeanne Dielman does errands, cares for a friend's baby, and cooks dinner for her son, adhering to a strict routine. She makes money through prostitution, taking one client each day.  The film takes place over the course of three days in Jeanne's life, and on the third day she br...

Beau Travail (1999)

  "You're not African anymore, you're a Legionnaire now."   So says Master Sergeant Galoup, who makes his beliefs about being in the French Foreign Legion very clear: it entails absolute devotion to one's superiors and priority of duty.  And yet, for some reason, he seems disturbed by Legionnaire Gilles Sentain, one of the soldiers stationed with him in Djibouti.  There's no reason for Galoup to hate Sentain.  The other soldiers adore him, as does the Commandant Forestier.   But Galoup accuses Sentain of being subversive.  He's constantly trying to warn Forestier about him, but Forestier won't listen.  Part of it is that Galoup is being unreasonable.  Part of it is that Forestier just isn't very interested.  Forestier lacks Galoup's fervor for the Legion, and never seems to exercise his authority.   Galoup keeps everything in perfect order.  Forestier lies back and doesn't do much of anything.  The soldiers swim and dance...

High and Low (1963)

I spoil something significant that happens halfway through this film, so don't read this before watching it if that bothers you. The film opens with credits over a few atmospheric shots of a smoky, crowded city set to somber music.  We find ourselves in a house standing at the top of a hill overlooking the city.  The owner of the home, and the main character of High and Low , is Kingo Gondo, an executive of National Shoes, played by Toshiro Mifune. He and the other executives of National Shoes argue over whether it's better to make flimsy shoes that will cost less to make, or durable shoes that will cost more.   The other executives insist on the former, arguing that shoes are an accessory.  But Gondo insists that shoes need to be more than that: a shoe must carry all of a person's weight.  This film could have also been called " Hats and Shoes " based on this scene.  It's not just that the other executives are so out of touch that they can't se...