Skip to main content

Posts

The last 3 Months: January-March 2024

I've been trying to balance my film-viewing with my work and making time for more literary fiction.  I recently read The Sparrow by Mary Doria Russell.  It's an upsetting book, but I appreciated that it doesn't seem like it's trying to go out of its way to shock you.  It helped me understand why I got that sense from Alex Garland's Men .  The Sparrow is a blunt instrument, but it's horror arises from an underlying, functional world.  It also dwells a great deal on the aftermath.  The above picture is from the 1943 adaptation of Ordet .  Naturally, I was curious about it because of Carl Theodor Dreyer's 1955 adaptation.  I was surprised to learn how much Dreyer cut from Kaj Munk's play.   The Counselor (2013) I saw this more as a Cormac McCarthy movie than a Ridley Scott movie.  The outline of the story is quite similar to that of No Country for Old Men : a capable but naive man tries to illicitly enrich himself by stepping outside his ...

Patlabor 2: The Movie

  Patlabor 2 features scenes of characters speaking at length, weighing, rationalizing, and speculating about the world and its history.  Oshii is a thinker, and this is the most blatant way he shows it in his films and tries to share his thinking with an audience.   Dense and memorable words can easily distract from the other elements of a film.  There are also many who will say that a film isn't supposed to have a "message"; such things would be better conveyed through nonfiction media.   Many of those viewers will tell you a movie's effect comes not from its "ideas," but its moods or illusionism.  Films have many dimensions.  We all know they can profoundly affect people's thinking and behavior.  Some people deny art affects reality at all, but I don't even think those people really believe that.  Still, it is true in some respect that "messages" or "ideas" don't have the significance a lot of people attribute to them....

The last 3 months: October-December 2023

I'm posting this so late that the title barely makes sense anymore.  So late that it unfortunately comes at a time when I'm compelled to pay respects to the memory of the great David Bordwell.  The banner image, from Moonrise Kingdom , is the image on the cover of Film Art: An Introduction , his book with Kristin Thompson.   For a long time, Bordwell and Thompson have struck me as having the most productive, informative, and personally edifying approach to closely viewing and discussing films.  It's an approach I often fear I don't live up to.  The rigor and knowledge they bring to the table seems vastly greater than almost anyone else's, and is certainly greater than my own.   At least, I've tried to avoid making far-fetched or baseless claims about films while still emphasizing why they are important, and the potential profundity of experience they offer.  My desire to strike this balance comes mainly from Bordwell and Thompson's influence...

Best First Watches of 2023

  There aren't many films listed here, but that's only because I've already written about a lot of my favorites.  In fact, I saw several films last year that I absolutely loved.  Compensation was the best.  It was my favorite film I'd seen since Letter from an Unknown Woman back in 2021; I'd vote for it in a Sight and Sound-type poll.  And Ludwig , First Cow , The Boy and the Heron , and Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore stand beside Compensation as films I found to be really new experiences that made me see things in a different light.  The films listed below are the remaining movies I saw in 2023 which I can say the same about.        Macario (1960) Macario is a man who lives in poverty.  When he sits down for dinner with his family, each person at the table gets only a small portion.  Macario always gives part of his to his many children.  He goes to bed hungry every night.  Eventually, he finds himself resenting...

The Boy and the Heron (2023)

The bulk of the film takes place through the looking glass, in a dreamlike underworld.  It's a world where people who enter from the outside gain a timeless existence.  New livelihoods manifest around the people who go there that reflect their aspirations and values.  Whenever someone enters the domain of the Towermaster, the world transforms to reflect their idea of paradise. In the real world, Mahito meets an elderly woman named Kiriko, one of the seven maids at Natsuko's home.  Kiriko appears in the underworld as a much younger woman.  There, a new life manifests for her.  She's sailor whose job it is to catch fish to feed the helpless inhabitants of an island in the middle of an endless sea.  She thinks she's always been there--she remembers nothing of her life in the real world.  Nevertheless, she possesses figurines of the other maids and treats them with reverence.  Because the maids are her friends, by this film's loose logic, she car...

The last three months: July-September 2023

I didn't watch that many movies in the last three months.  I'm hoping I'll have more to write about next time.   Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore (1974) Ellen Burstyn's Alice is the best performance in any of Martin Scorsese's films.  Alice walks on a knife's edge, and Burstyn captures the extreme stress she experiences.  But Burstyn simultaneously conveys the familial love and hope that Alice uses to power through the stress.   The film is unpredictable.  It lets us form expectations as the story heads off in one direction, then, there will be a sudden upheaval that sets it on a totally different course.  Sometimes the tone is ironic, sometimes it's harrowing.  And Burstyn's performance somehow works with all the different registers the film adopts.    That said, the film turns out to have a sort of tragic repetitiveness, something for Alice's dreams and the film's more romantic devices to struggle against.  The film isn...

The Wind Rises (2013)

Since this film came out, some people have had difficulty pinning down exactly how we should feel about its treatment of its main character, or Imperial Japan.  Bafflingly, some people also express uncertainty as to what Hayao Miyazaki  wants to say in this film.  If you're going to attribute the worldviews expressed in Miyazaki's films to Miyazaki himself, and if you knew anything about Miyazaki's political opinions, why would you be uncertain about this?  Miyazaki is not a good person.  He is egotistical, narrow-minded, and antisocial.  But his political beliefs are not obscure. That said, it's fair to be uncertain of what the film itself carries across, regardless of what Miyazaki or any of the other filmmakers intended.  But I don't think it's actually very ambiguous.  When Jiro meets Hans Castorp, Castorp tells Jiro how dangerous the Nazis and the intentions of the Japanese government are, and then mentions how he and Jiro have both come to a...