Skip to main content

Vertigo (1958)

Jimmy Stewart and Kim Novak standing together in the redwood forest.  They are very small in the frame, standing to the right of an enormous tree.  The leaves fill the background of the image with green, while the forest floor is a deep red.

I've never encountered anyone who called themselves an "aesthete" whom I thought I could be friends with.  Admittedly, I've met very few people like that.  I bring this up because I recall one of them criticizing Vertigo as only holding value for people who are into Lacanian psychoanalysis or meditations on memory like that in Chris Marker's Sans Soleil.  To be fair, there is a long history of people analyzing Vertigo and many of Hitchcock's other films in this way, and Freud is directly invoked in Marnie.  And since Hitchcock is a quintessential auteur, efforts to analyze his films, especially Vertigo, often involve efforts to analyze his psychology.

As a follower of Kristin Thompson, I tend to wonder if the Lacanian approach to film criticism isn't a little Procrustean.  In any case, I think the reason a lot of critics love Vertigo isn't really because of their Lacanian reads.  Consider this scene:

Stewart and Novak walk along a sidewalk under a blue sky with few clouds; behind them is a field of green grass, and behind that is a large structure with fancy architecture, built around a pond with fountains in it.

This image is from a single long take in which Scottie and Judy take a wordless stroll.  This scene is brief and mundane, and does not advance the narrative at all.  But it doesn't seem out of place.  Is it really any wonder why this would be in a movie?  You can imagine being a filmmaker, seeing a place like that, and thinking you'd like to include it in a film somehow.  

Vertigo is in large part a travelogue of San Francisco.  We visit the redwood forest, the Golden Gate Bridge, and the Legion of Honor.  Judy comments on what a lovely building the Legion of Honor is.  Not to mention the flower shop whose image has become an icon of this film.  Vertigo is in large part a travelogue of San Francisco, especially in this second movement but also elsewhere. 

When they stop at the redwood forest, Judy approaches a display featuring a cross-section of a tree.  The tree rings are marked with years and significant events that happened on those years.  1066 A.D., Battle of Hastings.  1215, Magna Carta signed.  1492, Columbus discovers America.  Mostly not things that happened on the continent where the redwoods actually grew--it's worth noting the most important scenes take place at a Spanish mission. 

In more ways than one, the film shows us the selection of beautiful things and their assembly into something compelling.  The film constructs the image of a city piece by piece, in the same way Scottie infamously attempts to construct the image of a woman.  

The film is far from naturalistic.  It features deep reds and greens that pop from the screen: near the Golden Gate Bridge, in the redwood forest, in the crimson-walled restaurant where Scottie first sees Judy, in the open fields surrounding San Juan Bautista, and in Judy's room at the Empire Hotel, where a green neon sign lights the room from just outside the window.  

The central drama depends on Scottie's dissatisfaction with his selection of images, with the fact that every selection is also an omission.  If I prefer Rear Window and North by Northwest to Vertigo, it's because they're more playful and ironic about this imperfection.  Rear Window shows us the silly or sleazy things underlying cultivated surfaces; North by Northwest is an extended competition of improvisation and manipulation.  Those two films are characterized by a pervasive amorality.  Vertigo is more judgmental.  

Maybe some people do like Vertigo because they enjoy applying Lacanian ideas to it.  It could just be about it looks and moves, too.  It may be more judgmental than Rear Window or North by Northwest, but it's also prettier.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The last 3 months: October-December 2021

The above image is from Kiyoshi Kurosawa's Eyes of the Spider .  Since it's close to the end of the year, I decided to use an image from what may be the best movie I saw this year, alongside Jia Zhangke's Platform . Belle (2021)  I had limited expectations for this movie.  I respect Mamoru Hosoda, but his greatest work remains the short movies and TV episodes he directed between 1999 and 2003, plus maybe The Girl Who Leapt Through Time .  His Studio Chizu movies have many of the same qualities that made those films great, but before Belle they generally shared some of the same basic elements: they start out with focus on the everyday life of a family, then through some encounter with the supernatural, they seek to show that the overwhelming power of idealized familial love can overcome anything.  It sometimes works. Since Belle is Hosoda's third movie about how people use the internet, I didn't expect any surprises from it.  I was wrong.  Its hopeful ...

My Neighbor Totoro (1988)

I had never seen Totoro on the big screen until recently.  I love all his movies, though it took me longer to come around to some of them than others.  Seeing Nausicaä , Kiki's Delivery Service , and Howl's Moving Castle in cinemas made a bigger difference than I expected in making me realize what's great about those films.   Maybe it's because the theater setting makes it easier for me to take in everything the film is doing holistically, and not just the logical connection of the narrative.  The famous scene in Totoro with Satsuki and Mei waiting for their father's bus at night, in the rain, struck me differently when there was no potential for distraction and there was nothing but the film in my field of view.  Mei starts nodding off and Satsuki lifts her onto her back.  At the same time, Satsuki struggles to hold the umbrella over them both.  For a few seconds, Satsuki just stands there in this awkward position, and we realize that...

One Battle After Another (2025)

The most hostile critiques I've read of this film mention issues with the production or the people involved.  Regardless of the subject matter of the film, one expects things like this from a film so mainstream with so many big-name actors.  Still, it's vexing when a film is so outwardly political, and the ugliest fact about the production is indeed pretty bad: the clearing of a homeless encampment in Sacramento for the filming.  This is a "political film" and decidedly not a "film made politically," in Godard's phrase. Its background and its priorities are closer to Christopher Nolan than The Hour of Liberation Has Arrived or Kanehsatake . I've seen convincing takes that don't suppose that it's trying to be like those films. Those films are not fantastical. One Battle After Another is indulging in a kind of fantasy when it depicts the French 75, its fictional radical-left militant faction. But through Benicio del Toro's character, Sen...