Skip to main content

Oppenheimer (2023)

Scientists construct the atom bomb, constructing large blocks of metal into a sphere, around a smaller core of refined uranium.

The film alternates between two frame stories which both involve hearings.  One is to renew J. Robert Oppenheimer’s security clearance and one to confirm Lewis Strauss (pronounced “Strawss,” he insists) as Secretary of Commerce.  Near the start of Strauss’s hearing, a senator makes a reference to “the Oppenheimer affair.” 

It’s clear that the hearing about Oppenheimer’s security clearance is a McCarthyist kangaroo court.  But their only question which fazes Oppenheimer is their most genuine: why did Oppenheimer, the father of the atomic bomb, turn around and become an opponent of hydrogen bombs?

The film opens with intellectual montage.  This is always thuddingly obvious, but that's not a problem when it's as effective as it is here.  In this movie, the montage is motivated largely by Oppenheimer's subjective experience.  Oppenheimer imagines the mysterious reality behind the world we perceive; Oppenheimer visits a museum and examines Picassos.  His interest in science is an aesthetic appreciation.  He’s almost childlike when the idea of a gravitationally collapsed object starts to form in his mind.  (There’s an anachronism in this movie where they say Oppenheimer wrote a paper on “black holes,” a term not used until the 1960s.)

The obviousness of what the montage means in the early parts of the film is important, because it sets the stage for the montage in later parts of the film.  Like Nolan's other films, Oppenheimer places asynchronous events and images in sequence.  The film is divided into scenes in Oppenheimer's perspective and scenes in Lewis Strauss's perspective.  Strauss's scenes are in black-and-white, and only the scenes within Oppenheimer's perspective have asynchronous editing.  

We understand it as flashes of Oppenheimer's memory or imagination.  Sometimes there are also shots of things in Oppenheimer's present that resemble things from his past.  Oppenheimer's powerful intellect motivates these elements, but past the opening scenes the film does not show him using it very much.  Rather, it highlights his spinelessness, takes away his plausible deniability whenever he says something to justify his support of building the bomb or refusal of responsibility for what it will do.

And because the story is told out of order, we have no context for some of the sounds and images that haunt Oppenheimer.  We see what his mind does but are still at some distance from exactly what he's thinking.  It gets to a point where the people railroading Oppenheimer are certainly antagonists, but Oppenheimer doesn't seem like a victim.  He's only vulnerable to them because of his own spinelessness.

When other scientists approach Oppenheimer and ask him to join them in discouraging the use of nuclear weapons, Oppenheimer does one of two things.  He might weakly say that his job as a scientist is just to discover and build, and that what is done with what he builds is not his decision.  Otherwise, he makes the rather absurd claim that once the world sees the terror of a nuclear weapon in use, all nations will come together in the cause of peace.  

After Hiroshima, Oppenheimer is brought to speak before the staff of the Manhattan Project.  They greet him with uproarious applause.  The bloodthirsty elation of his audience disturbs him, but even then, he's too weak to do anything but smile and give them the victory speech he senses they want.  

But one of the film's weaknesses the lack of any perspective other than Oppenheimer's.  Lewis Strauss doesn't count.  He exists in this film only to provide contrast that highlights the details it wants us to notice about Oppenheimer.  The only characters with views really different from Oppenheimer's are the people he meets early on from the Communist party at Berkeley.  The inquisitors repeatedly remind us that he associated with socialists, and we see many such meetings.  But there is no discussion of what any of those people actually believe, nor do any of them speak for themselves in the film, except for Jean Tatlock speaking of her personal relationship with Oppenheimer.  Not letting these characters speak keeps the film from seriously dealing with the questions it tries to raise.  It doesn't help that they include the film's only women characters, who the film ends up treating only as accessories to Oppenheimer.  

The greatest weakness, though, is the way it approaches the Trinity test.  The nuclear explosion is portrayed with the same overawed fascination Interstellar gave to black holes.  Later on, the film accuses Oppenheimer of trying to make the world remember him for Trinity and not Hiroshima and Nagasaki.  But the film itself commits similar whitewashing by failing to show how Trinity was also horrific.  This film's Bill-Nye-esque adoration of science is cute near the beginning when Oppenheimer hops between lectures by Niels Bohr and Werner Heisenberg talking about how Einstein opened the door to the quantum world.  Maybe part of the point is that Oppenheimer felt that way about the bomb.  But to persist with that way all the way through Trinity just buries the point.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The last 3 months: October-December 2021

The above image is from Kiyoshi Kurosawa's Eyes of the Spider .  Since it's close to the end of the year, I decided to use an image from what may be the best movie I saw this year, alongside Jia Zhangke's Platform . Belle (2021)  I had limited expectations for this movie.  I respect Mamoru Hosoda, but his greatest work remains the short movies and TV episodes he directed between 1999 and 2003, plus maybe The Girl Who Leapt Through Time .  His Studio Chizu movies have many of the same qualities that made those films great, but before Belle they generally shared some of the same basic elements: they start out with focus on the everyday life of a family, then through some encounter with the supernatural, they seek to show that the overwhelming power of idealized familial love can overcome anything.  It sometimes works. Since Belle is Hosoda's third movie about how people use the internet, I didn't expect any surprises from it.  I was wrong.  Its hopeful ...

My Neighbor Totoro (1988)

I had never seen Totoro on the big screen until recently.  I love all his movies, though it took me longer to come around to some of them than others.  Seeing Nausicaä , Kiki's Delivery Service , and Howl's Moving Castle in cinemas made a bigger difference than I expected in making me realize what's great about those films.   Maybe it's because the theater setting makes it easier for me to take in everything the film is doing holistically, and not just the logical connection of the narrative.  The famous scene in Totoro with Satsuki and Mei waiting for their father's bus at night, in the rain, struck me differently when there was no potential for distraction and there was nothing but the film in my field of view.  Mei starts nodding off and Satsuki lifts her onto her back.  At the same time, Satsuki struggles to hold the umbrella over them both.  For a few seconds, Satsuki just stands there in this awkward position, and we realize that...

One Battle After Another (2025)

The most hostile critiques I've read of this film mention issues with the production or the people involved.  Regardless of the subject matter of the film, one expects things like this from a film so mainstream with so many big-name actors.  Still, it's vexing when a film is so outwardly political, and the ugliest fact about the production is indeed pretty bad: the clearing of a homeless encampment in Sacramento for the filming.  This is a "political film" and decidedly not a "film made politically," in Godard's phrase. Its background and its priorities are closer to Christopher Nolan than The Hour of Liberation Has Arrived or Kanehsatake . I've seen convincing takes that don't suppose that it's trying to be like those films. Those films are not fantastical. One Battle After Another is indulging in a kind of fantasy when it depicts the French 75, its fictional radical-left militant faction. But through Benicio del Toro's character, Sen...