Skip to main content

Posts

The last three months: July-September 2023

I didn't watch that many movies in the last three months.  I'm hoping I'll have more to write about next time.   Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore (1974) Ellen Burstyn's Alice is the best performance in any of Martin Scorsese's films.  Alice walks on a knife's edge, and Burstyn captures the extreme stress she experiences.  But Burstyn simultaneously conveys the familial love and hope that Alice uses to power through the stress.   The film is unpredictable.  It lets us form expectations as the story heads off in one direction, then, there will be a sudden upheaval that sets it on a totally different course.  Sometimes the tone is ironic, sometimes it's harrowing.  And Burstyn's performance somehow works with all the different registers the film adopts.    That said, the film turns out to have a sort of tragic repetitiveness, something for Alice's dreams and the film's more romantic devices to struggle against.  The film isn...

The Wind Rises (2013)

Since this film came out, some people have had difficulty pinning down exactly how we should feel about its treatment of its main character, or Imperial Japan.  Bafflingly, some people also express uncertainty as to what Hayao Miyazaki  wants to say in this film.  If you're going to attribute the worldviews expressed in Miyazaki's films to Miyazaki himself, and if you knew anything about Miyazaki's political opinions, why would you be uncertain about this?  Miyazaki is not a good person.  He is egotistical, narrow-minded, and antisocial.  But his political beliefs are not obscure. That said, it's fair to be uncertain of what the film itself carries across, regardless of what Miyazaki or any of the other filmmakers intended.  But I don't think it's actually very ambiguous.  When Jiro meets Hans Castorp, Castorp tells Jiro how dangerous the Nazis and the intentions of the Japanese government are, and then mentions how he and Jiro have both come to a...

Oppenheimer (2023)

The film alternates between two frame stories which both involve hearings.  One is to renew J. Robert Oppenheimer’s security clearance and one to confirm Lewis Strauss (pronounced “Strawss,” he insists) as Secretary of Commerce.   Near the start of Strauss’s hearing, a senator makes a reference to “the Oppenheimer affair.”   It’s clear that the hearing about Oppenheimer’s security clearance is a McCarthyist kangaroo court.   But their only question which fazes Oppenheimer is their most genuine: why did Oppenheimer, the father of the atomic bomb, turn around and become an opponent of hydrogen bombs? The film opens with intellectual montage.    This is always thuddingly obvious, but that's not a problem when it's as effective as it is here.   In this movie, the montage is motivated largely by Oppenheimer's subjective experience.  Oppenheimer imagines the mysterious reality behind the world we perceive; Oppenheimer visits a museum and examines Pic...

Castle in the Sky (1986)

Castle in the Sky  is about two children, Pazu and Sheeta, who each have some attachment to the mythical floating island Laputa and the ancient civilization that lived there.  Pazu's late father once managed to photograph the island, and he wants to show the world that it's real.  Sheeta is a descendant of ancient Laputans who heard many stories about them from her grandmother.  There's also an evil government agent, Muska, who pursues Laputa because he believes it houses powerful weapons. It's an adventure film about looking for treasure.  Mamoru Oshii said it was one of the few Studio Ghibli movies he liked because it had a "good structure" for a "boy's adventure."  It isn't quite so solemn as NausicaƤ or Grave of the Fireflies .  (Oshii had some choice comments about that last one.) The world Pazu lives in feels antique in the characters' style of dress, their clunky machines, and their lifestyles.  I was not surprised to learn the v...

The last 3 months: April-June 2023

For once, most of these are films I actually went to go see in a theater.  Ponyo was a rewatch, but the last time I saw that movie, I was only 13.  I was excited to see that one, because I didn't love it when I first saw it.  So far, whenever I haven't been totally won over by one of Miyazaki's films, I've been blown away when I went to see it in a theater.  Ponyo  was no exception.  I've often found people's insistence the importance of the theater experience a little overstated or confusing, but these films have convinced me. Asteroid City (2023) Wes Anderson often has actors perform with low expression, and out of all his films this one may exemplify that the most.  I don't really perceive them as expressionless, but empty, portraying people drained of energy and expectation.  Many suggest Asteroid City is a film about grief, but if so, it's a late stage of grief, or the aftermath.  One has no more tears, but senses some emptiness behind t...

Ludwig (1973)

This film follows the "mad" king Ludwig's arc from the naive belief that everyone can understand the beauty of art, to his withdrawal from what he perceives as lowly politics, to his efforts to surround himself with people who will indulge his desires.  This last effort is not just Ludwig's effort to satisfy himself, but to be free from people he believes want to humiliate him.   It's not clear how much this behavior actually matters for the sound governance of Bavaria.  At some point, Otto von Bismarck's name is mentioned, and while he never appears in the film, it's clear that his authority is far more relevant than Ludwig's.  Many besides Ludwig are trying to govern while he withdraws. Different events of the story are introduced in flash-forwards to a government inquest into whether the king is mentally fit to rule, with officials, doctors, and other witnesses providing their opinions about what we are about to see.  Ludwig's chara...

How to Blow Up a Pipeline (2022)

  Spoilers ahead. The end credits of this film include a claim that it is inspired by Andreas Malm's book of the same title.  The book's full title is How to Blow Up a Pipeline: Learning to Fight in a World on Fire .  Some people started calling Malm a "terrorist" for writing this book, as if he's ever done anything terroristic other than gently suggest it to others.  His book argues that some illegal acts of property destruction can and should be used, in a strategically targeted way, by political activists in the movement seeking climate justice and mitigation of climate change. This is to say that this is a self-consciously political movie.  I've seen at least one person who said "agree with the group or not, the movie doesn't care and isn't about that," which is absurd.  It's true the filmmakers claimed influence from Ocean's Eleven and the film follows many conventions of the heist thriller genre; but in interviews, they say...